Retired LEGO sets: which themes gained most in value (2026 data)

By Alexis Pratsides, founder of CollectionPlnrUpdated

Own some? Track your LEGO free

Ninjago beats Star Wars. We tracked the current new-in-box value of 444 LEGO sets that retired between 2021 and 2026 against the price they cost in the shop. 71% now sell at or above their original retail price. But the theme you would bet on is not the theme that won. Ninjago sets lead every major line, while Star Wars, the theme most people buy as an investment, barely beats retail.

Here is what the numbers say, theme by theme, and what it means for the sets on your shelf right now.

The headline numbers

  • 71% of retired sets hold or beat retail. Of 444 sets retired since 2021, 315 are now worth at least what they cost new, and 303 are worth more.
  • The median retired set is worth 1.21x its retail price. A typical $50 set that has left the shelves now goes for around $60 new.
  • Nearly 1 in 10 has doubled. 9.5% of retired sets are worth twice their retail price or more.
  • Retirement is the trigger. Sets still on sale sit at a median of exactly 1.00x retail, and only half of them sell at or above it. The value gap opens when LEGO stops making a set.

Which themes gained most

Every theme with at least eight retired sets in our data, ranked by the median value of a retired set against its retail price.

ThemeRetired setsMedian value vs retailSets at or above retail
Ninjago301.55x93%
BrickLink Designer Program191.54x100%
Creator 3-in-1121.40x83%
Spider-Man91.40x89%
BrickHeadz111.35x91%
Batman91.33x89%
The Infinity Saga151.31x87%
City201.28x85%
Icons161.25x75%
Harry Potter241.18x67%
Speed Champions121.15x67%
Star Wars401.10x60%
Friends251.10x72%
Technic131.06x69%
DREAMZzz101.00x50%
Minecraft90.96x44%
Super Mario220.95x41%
Disney80.70x25%

Why Ninjago wins

Ninjago has the profile that makes a retired set climb. Its sets are bought by children who open them, so sealed boxes become scarce fast. It has a large adult fan base that grew up with the theme and now buys the sets it missed. And its biggest sets, like The Crystal King Temple (now 3.4x its $79.99 retail price) and The Keeper's Village (2.7x), are one-off designs that never come back.

Smaller Ninjago sets climb too. Tournament of Elements cost $29.99 and now sells for around $100. Lloyd's Mech Battle EVO cost $19.99 and now sells for over $60.

Why Star Wars lags

Star Wars is the theme collectors buy to hold, and that is exactly the problem. When thousands of people keep sealed copies of the same set, supply stays high after retirement and prices stay close to retail. LEGO also remakes popular Star Wars ships every few years, which caps what the older versions can fetch. Star Wars still beats retail on average, with 60% of retired sets at or above their shop price, but at a median of 1.10x it trails Ninjago, City and Friends.

The lesson for your own collection: the sets everyone is saving are rarely the sets that climb most.

The biggest risers

The retired sets that gained most against their retail price.

SetThemeRetailValue nowChange
Luigi's Mansion Lab and Poltergust (71397)Super Mario$29.99$140.684.7x
Minion Pilot in Training (75547)Minions$29.99$121.004.0x
The Crystal King Temple (71771)Ninjago$79.99$271.903.4x
Tournament of Elements (71735)Ninjago$29.99$99.993.3x
Lloyd's Mech Battle EVO (71781)Ninjago$19.99$63.393.2x
Thor's Hammer (76209)The Infinity Saga$99.99$296.053.0x
Batman Classic TV Series Batmobile (76188)Batman$29.99$84.992.8x
Spider-Man Final Battle (76261)Spider-Man$109.99$308.312.8x
Nano Gauntlet (76223)The Infinity Saga$69.99$189.992.7x
Koi Fish (40545)BrickHeadz$14.99$39.992.7x

Notice the Super Mario paradox. The theme as a whole sits below retail, yet its Luigi's Mansion expansion is the single biggest riser in the study. Within a weak theme, one set tied to a much-loved game can still take off. That is why you value set by set, never by theme alone.

The sets that fell

Retirement is no guarantee. Almost three in ten retired sets now sell below what they cost new. The biggest fallers are licensed tie-ins and play sets: Disney 100th Celebration (0.49x), Water Police Detective Missions (0.50x) and Technic Bugatti Bolide (0.60x). Sets made in large numbers for a moment in time rarely hold their value once that moment passes.

What this means for your collection

  • Buy before retirement, not after. Sets on sale sit at retail; the jump comes once they leave the shelves. Our guide to how LEGO retirements work shows you how to spot the sets about to go.
  • Keep it sealed. Every figure here is for new, sealed sets. An opened set is worth far less. See how to value a LEGO set.
  • Look past the obvious themes. Ninjago, City and Creator 3-in-1 outperformed Star Wars and Harry Potter.
  • Track what you own. Add your sets to CollectionPlnr and you see the current value of every set, and of your whole collection, in one place. Free, with no card needed.

How we worked this out

We took every LEGO set in our catalogue of 28,000+ sets that has both a US retail price of $10 or more and a current new, sealed market value updated within the last 60 days. A set counts as retired when its retirement date has passed: 444 sets retired between 2021 and 2026. For each set we divided today's market value by its original retail price. Theme figures are medians, so a single runaway set cannot skew a theme, and we only rank themes with at least eight retired sets. Values are in US dollars as of October 2026. Prices move: check the live value on any set page before you buy or sell.

Got LEGO of your own? Track yours

Log every set and minifigure you own and want, with market and retail prices side by side, so you know what your retired sets are worth. Free for up to 500 items, no card needed.

Track your LEGO