PSA vs CGC vs ACE: which grader should you use?

By Alexis Pratsides, founder of CollectionPlnr Prices as of November 2026

Quick answer

A 10 is not a 10. Across 304 cards with both listed, a CGC 10 lists for 54% of the same card's PSA 10 and a Beckett 9.5 for 71%. From the UK, CGC London and ACE grade without customs, which can matter more than the label on a cheaper card.

Picking a grader is a money decision. The label on the slab changes what buyers pay, and the cost of getting the card there changes what you keep. This guide puts both side by side, using the graded prices we track on every card.

What each grade lists for, next to a PSA 10

For every card with a PSA 10 and another grade both listed, we divide that grade's price by the PSA 10's. The median is the typical card; the middle half shows how much it swings. Based on 916 cards with a PSA 10 listed across Pokemon, One Piece, Lorcana, Magic and Yu-Gi-Oh!.

GradeOf a PSA 10Middle halfCards
PSA 10100%-916
BGS 10 Pristine1.65x1.18x to 2.41x111
CGC 10 Pristine1.15x0.99x to 1.36x141
TAG 101.04x0.93x to 1.20x132
BGS 9.571%60% to 82%178
ACE 1057%47% to 64%26
CGC 1054%44% to 64%304
CGC 9.536%25% to 49%39
TAG 935%28% to 50%49
BGS 934%26% to 43%41
PSA 933%23% to 43%492
CGC 926%17% to 35%104

Asking prices of current eBay listings for graded copies, refreshed every two weeks, newest 16 November 2026. A grade appears once at least eight cards have it listed next to a PSA 10.

How to read it

  • PSA's 10 sets the price. On most cards buyers pay most for it, and a PSA 9 lists for only 33% of a PSA 10. If your card is a real 10 candidate and worth a good sum, the PSA premium is usually worth the extra cost and wait.
  • Named 10s are their own thing. CGC's Pristine 10 lists for 1.15x a PSA 10 and Beckett's Pristine 10 for 1.65x, with Beckett's Black Label higher again. All are far rarer than a plain 10, so do not plan on one.
  • A cheaper grader can still win. On a card worth tens rather than hundreds, US post and import VAT can cost more than the PSA premium adds. That is where CGC London and ACE come in.
  • Every card is different. The middle-half column shows how wide the gap swings. Open the card itself: each card page shows its own graded prices, and the calculator compares every grader for that card.

What it costs to grade one card from the UK

Each grader's cheapest open service, per card, with VAT and insured post both ways spread over a small submission. Fees checked 8 November 2026.

GraderFeeVATPostAll in
CGC Bulk (London)≈ $15.84 (approximate conversion)$3.17$5$24.01
ACE Basic≈ $23.76 (approximate conversion)-$5$28.76
TAG Value$29.95$5.99$20$55.94
BGS Express$79.95$15.99$20$115.94
PSA Regular$79.99$16.00$20$115.99

VAT on US grading is import VAT on the fee when the card comes back, assuming you declare the card as returned goods; couriers may add a handling fee. Some cheap tiers need a minimum number of cards. PSA's Value tiers and Beckett's cheaper tiers are paused, so they are left out. Every tier, with turnaround, is in the grading calculator guide.

And comics?

CBCS stopped taking new books in April 2026, so comics grading is now CGC, with PSA grading comics since 2025. CGC's London centre takes modern books from £30, or £27 each in bulk, plus VAT, with no customs. Existing CBCS slabs stay valid, but buyers have long paid less for a CBCS 9.8 than a CGC 9.8, and that gap is unlikely to close now.

Run the numbers for your own card

Every card page with graded prices has a calculator: pick where you send from and your card's condition, and it compares every grader for that card, after fees, VAT and post. Track your slabs in your collection with grader, grade and certificate number, and your collection value uses the price for that grade. See the cards most worth grading.

Frequently asked questions

Is a CGC 10 worth the same as a PSA 10?▾

No. Across 304 cards with both listed, a CGC 10 lists for 54% of the same card's PSA 10 at the median. CGC's Pristine 10 is a different label and lists closer to, or above, a PSA 10.

Which grader is cheapest from the UK?▾

As of 8 November 2026, CGC's London centre starts at £12 a card plus VAT and ACE at £18, both graded in the UK with no customs. Sending to PSA or Beckett in the US means insured post both ways and import VAT on the fee when the card comes back.

Do I pay VAT when my graded cards come back from the US?▾

Usually you pay import VAT on the grading fee, not on the card, if you declare the card as returned goods when you send it. The courier may add a handling fee. Check the paperwork with your courier before you post.

Should I grade with ACE?▾

ACE is quick and cheap from the UK. Across 26 cards, an ACE 10 lists for 57% of a PSA 10. It makes most sense on cards where the cost of grading in the US would eat the gain.

Who grades comics now CBCS has closed?▾

CBCS stopped taking new comics in April 2026. CGC grades most comics and PSA started grading comics in 2025. CGC's London centre takes comics from £27 a book in bulk.

Prices are approximate and for guidance only. They are not a guarantee of what an item will sell for. See our terms.