Silver Age Key Comics

List as of October 9, 2026, from the CollectionPlnr catalog. Values are the median asking price of current eBay listings, not sold prices, checked October 8, 2026. For books before 1990 they cover every grade on offer.

Showing 1-60 of 189

1. 

   #1

   Fantastic Four #48 (1965)

   Marvel

   First appearance of Silver Surfer, Galactus.

   Galactus, Silver Surfer

   Asking price: $1,172CGC graded: 11,115

2. 

   #2

   Fantastic Four #52 (1966)

   Marvel

   First appearance of T'Challa, Black Panther.

   Black Panther, T'Challa

   Asking price: $650CGC graded: 8,586

3. 

   #3

   Daredevil #1 (1964)

   Marvel

   First appearance of Daredevil, Foggy Nelson, Karen Page.

   Daredevil, Foggy Nelson, Karen Page

   Asking price: $2,520CGC graded: 7,334

4. 

   #4

   Fantastic Four #50 (1966)

   Marvel

   First appearance of Wyatt Wingfoot.

   Wyatt Wingfoot

   Asking price: $300CGC graded: 5,265

5. 

   #5

   Fantastic Four #67 (1967)

   Marvel

   First appearance of Him.

   Him

   Asking price: $74.00CGC graded: 4,794

6. 

   #6

   Fantastic Four #45 (1965)

   Marvel

   First appearance of Black Bolt, Crystal, Karnak.

   Black Bolt, Crystal, Karnak

   Asking price: $197CGC graded: 4,496

7. 

   #7

   Captain America #117 (1969)

   Marvel

   First appearance of Falcon, Redwing. Origin of Sam Wilson. Origin of Falcon.

   Falcon, Redwing

   Asking price: $250CGC graded: 4,472

8. 

   #8

   Amazing Fantasy #15 (1962)

   Marvel

   First appearance of Peter Parker, Spider-Man, Aunt May. Origin of Peter Parker. Origin of Spider-Man. Death of Uncle Ben Parker.

   Aunt May, Peter Parker, Spider-Man

   Asking price: $8,500CGC graded: 4,258

9. 

   #9

   Detective Comics #359 (1966)

   DC

   First appearance of Batgirl.

   Batgirl

   Asking price: $700CGC graded: 4,023

10. Fantastic Four Annual #6

    #10

    Fantastic Four Annual #6 (1968)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Annihilus.

    Annihilus

    Asking price: $199CGC graded: 3,343

11. 

    #11

    Fantastic Four #1 (1961)

    Marvel

    First appearance of The Thing, The Human Torch, Mister Fantastic. Origin of Ben Grimm. Origin of Mole Man.

    Mister Fantastic, The Human Torch, The Thing

    Asking price: $6,000CGC graded: 3,320

12. 

    #12

    Tales of Suspense #39 (1962)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Tony Stark, Iron Man. Origin of Tony Stark. Origin of Iron Man.

    Iron Man, Tony Stark

    Asking price: $4,725CGC graded: 3,183

13. 

    #13

    Tales of Suspense #57 (1964)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Clint Barton, Hawkeye.

    Clint Barton, Hawkeye

    Asking price: $535CGC graded: 3,161

14. 

    #14

    Marvel Super-Heroes #13 (1967)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Carol Danvers.

    Carol Danvers

    Asking price: $98.98CGC graded: 2,855

15. 

    #15

    Strange Tales #110 (1963)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Dr. Strange, Wong, Ancient One.

    Ancient One, Dr. Strange, Wong

    Asking price: $2,239CGC graded: 2,760

16. 

    #16

    Journey into Mystery #83 (1962)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Thor, Doctor Donald Blake. Origin of Thor.

    Thor

    Asking price: $5,500CGC graded: 2,754

17. 

    #17

    Fantastic Four #5 (1962)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Doctor Doom.

    Asking price: $6,588CGC graded: 2,715

18. 

    #18

    Marvel Super-Heroes #12 (1967)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Captain Marvel, Colonel Yon-Rogg.

    Captain Marvel, Colonel Yon-Rogg

    Asking price: $103CGC graded: 2,536

19. 

    #19

    Marvel Super-Heroes #18 (1968)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Major Vance Astro, Yondu, Charlie-27.

    Charlie-27, Yondu

    Asking price: $241CGC graded: 2,520

20. 

    #20

    Tales of Suspense #52 (1964)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Natasha Romanoff, Black Widow.

    Black Widow, Natasha Romanoff

    Asking price: $660CGC graded: 2,513

21. 

    #21

    Fantastic Four #53 (1966)

    Marvel

    First appearance of T'Chaka.

    T'Chaka

    Asking price: $87.50CGC graded: 2,251

22. 

    #22

    Hawkman #4 (1964)

    DC

    First appearance of Zatanna.

    Zatanna

    Asking price: $700CGC graded: 2,076

23. 

    #23

    Journey into Mystery #85 (1962)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Loki, Odin, Balder.

    Balder, Loki, Odin

    Asking price: $1,749CGC graded: 2,057

24. 

    #24

    Fantastic Four #36 (1964)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Madam Medusa, Medusalith Amaquelin Boltagon.

    Asking price: $110CGC graded: 2,043

25. 

    #25

    Justice League of America #1 (1960)

    DC

    First appearance of Despero.

    Despero

    Asking price: $925CGC graded: 1,950

26. 

    #26

    Fantastic Four #94 (1969)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Agatha Harkness, Ebony.

    Agatha Harkness, Ebony

    Asking price: $85.00CGC graded: 1,814

27. 

    #27

    Strange Adventures #205 (1967)

    DC

    First appearance of Boston Brand, Deadman.

    Boston Brand, Deadman

    Asking price: $350CGC graded: 1,675

28. 

    #28

    Tales of Suspense #94 (1967)

    Marvel

    First appearance of MODOK.

    MODOK

    Asking price: $79.99CGC graded: 1,666

29. 

    #29

    Fantastic Four #13 (1963)

    Marvel

    First appearance of The Watcher, Red Ghost. Origin of Uatu. Origin of The Watcher.

    Red Ghost, The Watcher

    Asking price: $540CGC graded: 1,656

30. 

    #30

    Showcase #22 (1959)

    DC

    First appearance of Green Lantern, Carol Ferris.

    Carol Ferris, Green Lantern

    Asking price: $3,350CGC graded: 1,606

31. 

    #31

    Strange Tales #126 (1964)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Clea, Dormammu.

    Clea, Dormammu

    Asking price: $150CGC graded: 1,601

32. 

    #32

    Fantastic Four Annual #1 (1963)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Krang.

    Krang

    Asking price: $499CGC graded: 1,560

33. 

    #33

    Fantastic Four #19 (1963)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Nathaniel Richards, Pharaoh Rama-Tut.

    Nathaniel Richards, Pharaoh Rama-Tut

    Asking price: $400CGC graded: 1,471

34. 

    #34

    Fantastic Four #33 (1964)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Attuma.

    Attuma

    Asking price: $99.50CGC graded: 1,447

35. 

    #35

    Fantastic Four #65 (1967)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Ronan the Accuser, The Supreme Intelligence.

    Ronan the Accuser

    Asking price: $60.00CGC graded: 1,447

36. 

    #36

    Tales to Astonish #27 (1961)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Henry Pym.

    Henry Pym

    Asking price: $3,750CGC graded: 1,446

37. 

    #37

    Tales to Astonish #44 (1963)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Janet Van Dyne, Wasp.

    Janet Van Dyne, Wasp

    Asking price: $1,250CGC graded: 1,439

38. Vampirella #1

    #38

    Vampirella #1 (1969)

    Warren

    First appearance of Vampirella.

    Vampirella

    Asking price: $1,475CGC graded: 1,344

39. 

    #39

    Journey into Mystery #84 (1962)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Jane Foster.

    Jane Foster

    Asking price: $528CGC graded: 1,302

40. 

    #40

    Showcase #34 (1961)

    DC

    First appearance of The Atom.

    The Atom

    Asking price: $300CGC graded: 1,188

41. 

    #41

    Strange Tales #138 (1965)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Eternity.

    Eternity

    Asking price: $55.40CGC graded: 1,173

42. 

    #42

    Tales to Astonish #90 (1967)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Abomination, Emil Blonsky. Origin of Abomination. Origin of Emil Blonsky.

    Abomination, Emil Blonsky

    Asking price: $99.00CGC graded: 1,160

43. Fantastic Four Annual #5

    #43

    Fantastic Four Annual #5 (1967)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Psycho-Man.

    Psycho-Man

    Asking price: $75.00CGC graded: 1,133

44. 

    #44

    Fantastic Four #11 (1962)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Impossible Man, Willie Lumpkin.

    Impossible Man, Willie Lumpkin

    Asking price: $320CGC graded: 1,125

45. 

    #45

    Fantastic Four #47 (1965)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Maximus.

    Maximus

    Asking price: $45.00CGC graded: 1,120

46. 

    #46

    Strange Tales #159 (1967)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Contessa Valentina Allegra de Fontaine.

    Contessa Valentina Allegra de Fontaine

    Asking price: $60.00CGC graded: 1,107

47. 

    #47

    Fantastic Four #15 (1963)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Mad Thinker, Awesome Android. Origin of Awesome Android.

    Awesome Android, Mad Thinker

    Asking price: $400CGC graded: 988

48. 

    #48

    Daredevil #18 (1966)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Gladiator.

    Gladiator

    Asking price: $66.50CGC graded: 954

49. 

    #49

    Thor #148 (1967)

    Marvel

    First appearance of The Wrecker, Dirk Garthwaite. Origin of Blackagar Boltagon. Origin of Black Bolt.

    The Wrecker

    Asking price: $52.00CGC graded: 933

50. 

    #50

    Journey into Mystery #102 (1964)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Sif, Hela.

    Hela, Sif

    Asking price: $200CGC graded: 888

51. 

    #51

    Fantastic Four #62 (1967)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Blastaar.

    Blastaar

    Asking price: $37.25CGC graded: 886

52. 

    #52

    Journey into Mystery #86 (1962)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Odin.

    Odin

    Asking price: $214CGC graded: 883

53. 

    #53

    Fantastic Four #30 (1964)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Diablo.

    Diablo

    Asking price: $102CGC graded: 853

54. 

    #54

    Action Comics #242 (1958)

    DC

    First appearance of Brainiac.

    Brainiac

    Asking price: $2,150CGC graded: 810

55. 

    #55

    Showcase #73 (1968)

    DC

    First appearance of The Creeper.

    The Creeper

    Asking price: $87.50CGC graded: 788

56. 

    #56

    Thor #154 (1968)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Mangog.

    Mangog

    Asking price: $53.35CGC graded: 785

57. 

    #57

    My Greatest Adventure #80 (1963)

    DC

    First appearance of Cliff Steele, Negative Man, Elasti-Girl.

    Cliff Steele, Elasti-Girl, Negative Man

    Asking price: $450CGC graded: 781

58. 

    #58

    Tales to Astonish #62 (1964)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Leader.

    Leader

    Asking price: $100CGC graded: 735

59. 

    #59

    Tales to Astonish #63 (1964)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Leader.

    Leader

    Asking price: $130CGC graded: 722

60. 

    #60

    Thor #129 (1966)

    Marvel

    First appearance of Ares.

    Ares

    Asking price: $70.69CGC graded: 717